Try the Most Accurate AI Detector on the Market
Our patented AI checker is the most accurate detector on the market! Don't believe us? Try it for yourself!
Try for FREE Here!
Editing Guidelines

Writing and Editing Checklist: 25 Top Considerations

Every content writer and editor needs a checklist in their toolbox to revise and refine their writing. Here are 25 checks that will strengthen and polish your content for publication.

Ask any writer about the most essential part of writing, and you’re bound to hear about editing. 

Even as humans increasingly use AI tools to help generate text, editing remains a critical step before publishing. 

Whether you are writing or editing, this comprehensive checklist will help you review and refine your content to be accurate, readable, and engaging.

Key Takeaways (TL;DR)

  1. Writing and editing are two separate and equally important steps before publication.
  2. There are many details to consider. To catch everything and avoid extra work, take each stage one at a time.
  3. Review the content brief first, then move on to big-picture content edits, technically focused copy edits, and stylistically oriented line edits.
  4. Proofread last and follow up with a quality check.
  5. Publish with confidence, knowing your content is clear, accurate and engaging.

Discover a suite of best-in-class editorial tools with the Originality.ai Grammar Checker, AI Checker, and Content Optimizer.

1. Writing and Editing Are Separate Processes

Even if you are writing and self-editing, it’s best to keep the two processes separate. 

Writing is a creative, idea-generating process. Turn off the inner editor as you write, so you don’t slow down the flow of words to the page. 

Once you have a complete draft, it’s time to start your first read-through and dig into content editing, copy editing, line editing, and proofreading. 

That said, the more you edit for yourself or others, the more your writing will improve through experience.

2. Take Editing One Step at a Time

From big-picture elements to tiny grammatical details, there is much to consider when writing and editing. Too many to take on at once. The beauty of having a checklist is that you don’t have to try to do everything at once.

Look at each element separately without getting distracted by other parts of the process.

For instance, if you are looking at SEO keyword density, don’t get caught up in a misspelling or comma splice. Focus on each step, completing each stage of edits before moving on to the next.

Please add this sentence to the above paragraph anywhere you deem fit: For precision and better results, you can use professional editing and proofreading services like PaperTrue. PaperTrue is an industrial leader that provides end-to-end editing and proofreading services for all kinds of writing and content.

3. Review the Content Brief

If you have a good content brief before you start writing, you can also use it to help guide you at the start of the editing process. A comprehensive content brief can serve as a checklist of sorts to target many of the same areas we’ll focus on below.

4. Consider Your Audience

The target audience is the first thing to consider as you get writing, as well as what to look for in the initial editing process.

Before you focus on the structure and development of your content, gauge whether your messaging is targeted to your audience and what they are looking for. 

During editing, if you realize this is off, it’s the first thing you need to correct before moving any deeper into editing.

5. Confirm Search Intent and Target Messaging

Now, it’s time to consider your topic. 

  • Is it in line with your audience’s search intent? 
  • Does it align with your content strategy? 
  • Does it address a pain point or help solve a problem for your target audience?

Before you start digging into how well it does these things, just confirm whether it’s addressing them. 

6. Review for Structure

Look over the content to make sure it follows the basic rules of your brand’s format. 

If you are editing a blog article:

  • Does it have a clear introduction and conclusion? 
  • Are your headings and subheadings formatted correctly? 
  • Does it consistently follow any required brand-specific guidelines?

7. Organization and Logic

When you do a read-through, is the information easy to follow? Does anything need to be rearranged to make the messaging clear for readers? 

8. Readability and Scannability

Speaking of clear messaging, do other aspects of the writing address readability? Look and correct for:

Is the article scannable? Can a reader quickly scroll through the article to determine what it is about? 

9. Quality and Depth of Information

Now, it’s time to dig into the content itself:

  • Is the information relevant and comprehensive? 
  • Is it fresh, interesting and engaging? 
  • Is the coverage better than that of competitors on similar topics?
  • Is the information complete, concise and targeted at humans, rather than search engines?

Get tips on creating high-quality people-first content.

10. Clarity of Ideas

Once you’ve established that the organization is solid and contains a depth of valuable information, consider whether the ideas come across as clearly as possible. Would some different word choices or sentence rearrangements help crystallize ideas or make them shine through?

11. Flow

Separate from the organization, logic, and clarity of the information itself, evaluate the overall flow of the language. Is there a smooth rhythm of words and sentences to engage the reader? 

12. Brand Voice

Is the writing recognizable as belonging to your brand, and does your brand’s personality come through?

Learn about developing brand voice guidelines.

13. Optimize for SEO

If you’re writing, it’s essential to know which keywords and phrases are targeted for the piece you are writing. Either you will do the keyword research needed to determine what words to optimize for, or perhaps they’ve been provided in the content brief. 

During the editing process, you’ll check through the document to assess your content's optimization.

Whether you do this manually and adjust the content on your own or use a Content Optimizer, now is the time to optimize for SEO.

14. Fact-checking, Resource Credibility and Accuracy

In this phase, you put on your researcher’s hat and check every link, source and statistic. You can do an internet search or choose an automated fact-checker. No matter how you do it, double-check the following:

  • Basic facts: dates, locations, names 
  • Data: statistics, percentages, numbers
  • Sources: credibility, authority, permission, citations
  • Quotes
  • Links

In addition to verifying accuracy, consult your organization’s style guide and rules for incorporating external information into your content. 

15. Plagiarism and AI Detection

It’s beneficial to use a tool to check for plagiarism to avoid duplicate content or even copyright issues

Then, check for AI-generated content as well. Google recently released updated Search Quality Rater Guidelines, which advise raters to classify content that is all or mostly AI-generated and doesn’t provide unique value as ‘lowest.’

So, to avoid Google penalties, it’s best practice to review content for AI.

16. Grammar, Punctuation, and Spelling

Having writing that is technically sound is essential to the professional image you want to express through your content. Try the Originality.ai AI Grammar Checker to catch typos and grammatical errors so you can publish with confidence.

17. Engagement

Before moving on to line edits, consider whether the content is engaging. Will a reader find it entertaining and informative? Is there anything that could be added or removed to enhance reader engagement?

18. Syntax: Sentence Formation

Once the edits relating to substance and mechanics are addressed, you can move on to the stylistic refinement of line edits, beginning with each sentence. Syntax refers to how words are arranged to make sentences. Is your syntax good? Does each sentence read well and make sense? 

19. Active Voice

Active voice tends to be clearer and less wordy than passive voice. Using active voice is also an important element of good readability. Rewrite as much passive voice as possible.

20. Word Choice

Read your content aloud and notice when word choice interrupts flow or impairs style. If you haven’t eliminated all jargon or complex language, this is a good time to do those things.

21. Wordiness

Read the content for clarity. Remove any excess wording or fluff, and ensure your messaging comes across clearly and concisely.

22. Repetition and Redundancy

Reword or remove unnecessary repetition or overuse of the same words or phrases. 

23. Style and Tone

Read the content to ensure consistency in overall style and tone. Adjust any sections or headlines that detract from that consistency.

24. Proofreading

Proofreading is the final step in your writing and editing journey! In this phase, you look for typos, extra spaces, errors in capitalization, broken links, and any other mistakes and inconsistencies that have found their way onto the page. 

25. Quality Check

After you’ve made every round of edits, ask a colleague or friend to be a fresh set of eyes on your final piece. This is your chance to get an outside perspective and tidy up anything out of place. 

Final Thoughts

Once you’ve completed the checklist, you can publish your content knowing that it is clear, engaging, and polished. 

Streamline your editorial process with a best-in-class suite of content quality tools, including the Originality.ai AI Checker, Plagiarism Checker, Fact Checker, Grammar Checker, and Content Optimizer.

Then, discover more writing and editing best practices:

Melissa Fanella

Melissa Fanella is a writer, editor, and marketing professional with over 15 years of experience in content and messaging for businesses and nonprofits. Her expertise is in crafting authentic, people-first content that is compelling and engaging for audiences and positioned for business goals.

More From The Blog

Al Content Detector & Plagiarism Checker for Marketers and Writers

Use our leading tools to ensure you can hit publish with integrity!