Try the Most Accurate AI Detector on the Market
Our patented AI checker is the most accurate detector on the market! Don't believe us? Try it for yourself!
Try for FREE Here!
AI Studies

Human-Written Websites are Worth 39% More Than AI-Generated Websites: Study

Based on 12 months of website sales data from Motion Invest, this study set out to determine whether AI use impacts the sale price of websites valued at $6000 or more. These are our findings.

Like it or not, AI-generated content is becoming more common across online platforms.

Key Finding: 

Publishing AI-generated content is considered risky, as Google has penalized AI-heavy sites, leading buyers to pay 39% more on average for sites with no AI content. Based on a study by the website buying and selling marketplace MotionInvest.com

In addition to popping up in Google results or Reddit posts, AI content is now a critical part of how websites that people are buying and selling get valued.

Although the use of AI isn’t necessarily a problem in and of itself, buyers know that there are both pros and cons to AI-generated content. And when money’s on the line - especially at higher price points - even a little uncertainty can impact the risk and resulting price a buyer is willing to pay.

To investigate this, we conducted a study on how the use of AI content (either fully, partially, or for grammar support) affects the sale price and time on market of websites based on real transaction data from Motion Invest.

Motion Invest is a website marketplace that offers content sites ranging from $800 to over $1 million, making it an excellent data source for our particular study. This platform specializes in vetted, profitable sites, making it a reliable source for studying how AI sites affect buyer behaviour.

Notably, it is the only marketplace that discloses and uses Originality.ai’s AI detector to verify if the website's content is AI-generated or human-written. 

Objectives of the Study

Based on 12 months of website sales data from Motion Invest, this study set out to:

  • Determine whether the use of AI content impacts the sale price of websites that sold for $6000 or more.
  • Measure how AI use on these sites affects their time on market.
  • Explore the potential implications of AI-generated content on website valuations and buyer behaviour.

Key Takeaways (TL;DR)

  • From May 2024 to April 2025, Human content-only websites sold for 39% more than websites that had AI content on them.
  • AI sites stayed on the market an average of 19 days longer than those without, a difference of 54%.
  • These results show that buyers view AI content as risky and are willing to pay less for sites that have AI content on them.
Key Takeaways

Websites Written By Humans Sell for 39% More Than Websites With AI Writing On Them 

Websites Written By Humans Sell for 39% More Than Websites With AI Writing On Them 

Our analysis of Motion Invest’s website sales (defined as those that sold for $6,000 or more) from May 2024 to April 2025 reveals that, on average, the use of AI negatively impacted sale price.

More specifically, AI sites sold for lower sales multiples (a metric that compares sale price to monthly revenue). AI sites sold for an average of 1.5x annual revenue sale multiple, while those without AI use sold for 2.1x annual revenue.

This data suggests a strong correlation between the use of AI content on websites and buyer behavior. However, other valuation factors may also come into play here. Niche, traffic trends, monetization methods, and other factors can all impact the sale price.

AI Sites Took 54% Longer to Sell

AI Sites Took 54% Longer to Sell

Our study also revealed another pattern: Websites that had AI content took longer to sell than those that didn’t.

The difference in the average time on the marketplace proved to be quite significant. Sites that didn’t use AI spent on average 35 days on the market, while those that did sat for 54 days until they were sold.

On average, it took 19 more days, or 54% longer, to sell websites with AI-generated content than those without.

These results clearly indicate that buyers perceive AI-generated content as risky.

Implications of AI for Website Valuations and Buyer Behaviour

Implications of AI for Website Valuations and Buyer Behaviour

A decrease in sales multiples and an increase in time on market highlight the potential impact that AI has on website purchasing decisions, signalling a shift in how buyers evaluate digital assets.

Of course, AI use didn’t prevent sales in this study, which is good news for site owners who rely on some type of AI to help run their websites. 

However, consistently lower sale prices suggest that sites with only human-written content are seen as more valuable/less risky. If that trend continues, sites with only human content could stand out even more in the market.

Tools like AI detectors and Site Scans could end up playing an important role here, as they can help both buyers and sellers flag potential instances of low-effort AI-assisted content. 

Methodology

Data Scope:

  • 12 months of sales data from Motion Invest (May 2024–April 2025).
  • Focused only on content websites that sold for $6,000 or more.

Exclusions:

  • Sites sold for less than $6,000 were excluded to avoid skewed data due to differing buyer behaviour at lower price points.
  • Websites with complex monetization or traffic sources were excluded to ensure we were minimizing the variables.
  • YouTube Channels sold were excluded as they fall outside the scope of web content analysis.

Final Dataset: 28 qualifying website transactions.

  • 11 AI websites
  • 17 Human Content only websites

AI Site Classification

AI Sites specified "Yes" to AI Disclosure: Sellers explicitly stated AI content was used (either fully, partially, or for grammar support).

Sites without AI specified "No" to AI Disclosure: Sellers stated they didn’t use AI, and this was verified by the team at MotionInvest with Originality.ai’s AI Checker scans of multiple pages.

Final Thoughts

Overall, the results of this study demonstrate that the presence of AI-generated content on websites is actively shaping buyer behavior

If sellers want to avoid lower sale prices and longer times on market, it may be worth highlighting human-written content in website marketplace listings

Sellers can:

  • Use AI detection tools to screen their websites for low-effort or unedited AI content
  • Offer disclosures about how content is created or reviewed

Buyers can:

  • Use AI checkers to help evaluate website content before purchase

Need a quick way to evaluate AI use before buying or selling a website? Scan content with Originality.ai’s AI Detector and Bulk Scan today.

Further Reading:

Jonathan Gillham

Jonathan Gillham

Founder / CEO of Originality.ai I have been involved in the SEO and Content Marketing world for over a decade. My career started with a portfolio of content sites, recently I sold 2 content marketing agencies and I am the Co-Founder of MotionInvest.com, the leading place to buy and sell content websites. Through these experiences I understand what web publishers need when it comes to verifying content is original. I am not For or Against AI content, I think it has a place in everyones content strategy. However, I believe you as the publisher should be the one making the decision on when to use AI content. Our Originality checking tool has been built with serious web publishers in mind!

More From The Blog

Al Content Detector & Plagiarism Checker for Marketers and Writers

Use our leading tools to ensure you can hit publish with integrity!