Try the Most Accurate AI Detector on the Market
Our patented AI checker is the most accurate detector on the market! Don't believe us? Try it for yourself!
Try for FREE Here!
AI Studies

How Originality.ai Could Have Prevented the AI-Generated Book List Scandal

Several US newspapers published a list of books credited to real authors that were, in fact, AI hallucinations. Could this have been prevented? We used our proprietary Originality.ai AI Detection and Fact Checking software to find out!

Several newspapers in the USA, including reputable papers such as the Chicago Sun-Times and The Philadelphia Inquirer, have published a summer book list (depicted in the image below) in which the majority of the listed titles do not actually exist. 

These books, which are credited to several real and reputable authors, may sound like amazing summer reads — but really, they’re AI hallucinations.

How Originality.ai Could Have Prevented the AI-Generated Book List Scandal
Image depicting the summer reading list published in the Chicago Sun-Times

It turns out that the #1 rated book on the list, called “Tidewater Dreams,” by famous Chilean author Isabel Allende doesn’t actually exist and that the “Nightshade Market”, by popular authors Min Jin Lee, was never written. 

How Originality.ai Could Have Prevented the AI-Generated Book List Scandal

Moreover — only five of the 15 titles on the published list are real.

At Originality.ai, this kind of story gets our attention because it shows the real-world consequences from brand reputation damage and the clear breach of journalistic integrity that underscores exactly why we built our tools — to give editorial teams the ability to verify their content and protect their integrity. 

So, Could This Have Been Prevented?

Absolutely! Had a quick and simple scan using Originality.ai’s patented technology been conducted on this content prior to publication, this would have caught the problem by leveraging both the AI Detection Feature and the Fact-Checking Feature.

Had this list been run through Originality.ai, the whole mess could’ve been avoided in under 30 seconds…. Our tool would have flagged the AI-generated text and fact-checked whether the books even existed.

The cost?

14 cents.

Yes, you read that right FOURTEEN CENTS to protect a publication’s credibility, avoid public embarrassment, and uphold basic journalistic standards.

We’re genuinely puzzled why major editorial teams are still skipping this step when the solution is fast, cheap, and literally built for them?

How AI Detection Could Have Been Used 

Our industry-leading AI Detector accurately flags AI-generated text across a massive subset of LLMs (Large Language Models). It works by leveraging supervised learning of a carefully fine-tuned large AI language model.

We’ve built our own LLM, and then we feed this model millions of carefully selected records of known AI and known human content. It has learned to recognize patterns between the two with 99% accuracy.

AI Detection scans are useful for checking website and blog content, student essays, and in this case, our AI Checker would have flagged this book list as Likely AI with 100% Confidence. There’s no wiggle room for misinterpretation here. 

How AI Detection Could Have Been Used 

How Automated Fact-Checking Could Have Been Used

Originality.ai’s patented Fact Checker is a real-time, accurate fact-checking aid that helps you reduce false facts and avoid AI hallucinations, so you can publish content with integrity. 

We scanned this book list using our fact-checking software, which immediately highlighted and flagged all of the fictitious books in question and clearly stated that they did not exist

How Automated Fact-Checking Could Have Been Used

Check out the full scan here: Click here to view the public scan results

Why It Matters

It’s 2025 — the internet is being flooded with AI-generated content. 

The damage control that the publications now face due to this mishap seems disproportionate to the accessibility and affordability of content validation tools built specifically to prevent situations like these. 

It’s clear: a quick check could have saved time, embarrassment, and credibility.

If you are a journalist, an editor, a publisher or a content marketer and want to avoid situations where your credibility and integrity are jeopardized, start using Originality.ai today. 

Interested in reading more about AI? Check out our AI Studies.

Madeleine Lambert

Madeleine Lambert

Madeleine Lambert is the Director of Marketing and Sales at Originality.ai, with over a decade of experience in SEO and content creation. She previously owned and operated a successful content marketing agency, which she scaled and exited. Madeleine specializes in digital PR—contact her for media inquiries and story collaborations.

More From The Blog

Al Content Detector & Plagiarism Checker for Marketers and Writers

Use our leading tools to ensure you can hit publish with integrity!